Rights and Responsibilities - Coffee with Steven

Rights and Responsibilities

Rights and Responsibilities



“Mr. Lieberman, would you be willing to handle a lawsuit?”



“Why don’t you tell me the facts.”



“I want to challenge the law.”



“Always encouraged to hear that… what law?”



“The law requiring me to get a CCW to carry a gun.”



“Ahhh… you think we should be Constitutional Carry?”



“I do… and even if they mandate a CCW, there should be no fee, and no training requirement.  I should not have to spend any money to exercise a fundamental right!”



“Just out of curiosity… do you train regularly?”



“I don’t need to train!  I already own guns!”




He has a point, you know.



I had this conversation with a retiree last week here at Artemis. He’s not one of our Artemis clients, mind you, just an individual who has seen some of my videos and decided to see if I would be interested in handling a case pro-bono as a civil rights issue.



Let us begin with my philosophical underpinnings; I am somewhat of an absolutist on this front.



1) I believe you own your body.  You are not the property of the State.  Your corporal “self” is not on lease to you by some government agency.



2) Since you own your body, you can choose to do what you want with your body, including what you put into it, and denying others the ability to put stuff into it.  Like I said, it is yours and you have complete sovereign ownership of it.



3) This also means you are free to contract the use of your body in whatever manner you see fit.  If you want to sell your physical labor, you can.  If you want to sell your mental labor, you can.  Licensing, guilds / unions, etc. are wonderful things to join that may very well make you more valuable to your customers and, therefore, give you the ability to command a higher price for your service… but I am antagonistic to mandating licensing in general.  (Remember… I am a purist… this incidentally also includes being against mandatory membership in the bar, of which I am a member for both California and the District of Columbia.)



4) Rights preexist the Constitution and were granted to us by God.  The Constitution does not grant rights… it recognizes rights.  Rights, incidentally, are not geographically dependent; they are universal and exist everywhere.  Many, if not most, other countries are not enlightened enough to recognize these preexisting rights… but they do exist even in their own jurisdictions.  We are blessed that our Framers did recognize them and codified them in our Constitution.



5) All rights come with responsibilities.  This unique right we exercise, the bearing of arms, comes with more than a simple responsibility… it comes with a moral mandate, as you have heard me say countless times.  You need to be training constantly, consistently, repetitively, and with purpose.



So… back to the concept of fees / costs and the bearing of arms.  Am I against it?  Yes… I am philosophically consistent in that aspect. Just like I believe there should be no financial restrictions on exercising your First or Fourth Amendment rights, there should be no governmental restrictions on exercising your Second Amendment rights.  That said, refusal to do so makes you a pariah and a danger to society.  Those who believe simply owning a gun or occasionally going to the range and punching paper or pinging steel makes them a gunfighter are sorely mistaken.



The fact they are so cavalier in their own safety is troubling.  The fact their irresponsible behavior can affect innocent bystanders is unacceptable.



One of my heroes, LTC Jeff Cooper, famously stated, “Owning a gun and considering yourself a shooter is the equivalent of owning a piano and considering yourself a concert pianist.”



I think this sums up my feelings nicely.



Do I think there should be restrictions on this person’s ability to carry a gun?






Do I think there should be restrictions on my ability to chastise this way of thinking by exercising my First Amendment rights?






Recent Posts

Saint Alive! Blog - Catacombs

Saints Alive!

The sounds of dripping were muffled by the hiss of the torch.  I could feel the oil-laden rag at the end of the truncheon burning

Read More »
PAGA(Private Attorneys General Act) Blog


One of the most infuriating aspects of Constitutional Law is the need to remain philosophically consistent, even when… especially when… outcomes on specific cases seem

Read More »
Cain Abel & the Vote Blog

Cain, Abel, and the Vote

Why did Cain kill Abel?     Seriously… what was the real motivation?  Jealousy?  That seems like a spectacularly one-dimensional excuse frankly.  I think it

Read More »

Comments (4)

  • Christopher S. Martin Reply

    I thoroughly enjoy your blogs. I look forward to and read them every week. What you said is absolutely true with regards to rights and responsibilities. I am an absentee member of Artemis. My membership is/was through the Special Forces Association chapter 78 but I have since moved to Tennessee for various reasons many of which have been highlighted in your blogs. I retired from the military after getting wounded in Afghanistan, but I also retired from the Long Beach Police Department where my final assignment was the Range Sergeant. I can say that I know guns. Yes, I have several. But, just because I own firearms and carry them legally, doesn’t make me an expert. It makes me a law abiding citizen. The fact that I train as often as I can is what makes me responsible enough to enjoy my second amendment right. Because of my HR 218 requirement, I must requalify annually. I don’t mind. I gives me an opportunity to prove that I am responsible and competent enough to carry.

    I will be looking forward to your next blog.

    Please give my regards to the LTC and any members of Chapter 78.

    11/01/2023 at 10:50
  • Robert Hagler Reply

    Thanks for articulating both sides of the argument for training, and CCW permits.
    The quote above: “The Constitution does not grant rights… it recognizes rights” is powerful!
    And as you also said, “You need to be training constantly, consistently, repetitively, and with purpose.”
    This is a well balanced approach, in my opinion also.

    11/01/2023 at 21:51
  • Olaf Kilthau Reply


    11/02/2023 at 08:58
  • Norm Ellis Reply


    11/04/2023 at 17:33

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *