Artemis Banner for Blog: The Tocqueville, Paradox

The Tocqueville Paradox

The Tocqueville Paradox

China has been on our collective minds recently, hasn’t it? 

From displays of naval sea power off the coast of Taiwan, to infectious pathogens walking out of a viral disease laboratory in Wuhan, to some dude eating a boiled bat, China has caused us both fear and intrigue. 

One of our major concerns (or at least it should be) is that China is essentially a totalitarian dictatorship.  We know this… but they sell us cheap crap we can pick up at deeply discounted prices at Costco… so we watch our giant screen TVs, enjoy our inexpensive (relatively) cell phones, and conveniently ignore the plight of their people. 

De Opresso Liber.

(Unless the “opresso” is funding a new public works project in your district.)

So, rather than spend our time pondering the fate of China (pro tip:  long term it’s not good), let’s look at some rather interesting political dynamics that have taken place at home. 

California, New York, and Michigan have enacted some incredible draconian central policies.  Not laws… for the most part, gubernatorial edicts that have been enforced as laws.  These policies have abrogated the people’s constitutional rights, have been arbitrary and capricious, and have hidden behind “science” as a pathetic justification for supplanting citizens’ rights to choose how to organize their lives and secure their protection for the more erudite, acceptable desires of their rulers. 

We call this a dictatorship.

President Trump pontificated that he would like to see businesses reopen.  Soon.  Well… some businesses… tattoo parlors and spas… well… he doesn’t like tattoo parlors and spas… they should stay closed.  But the businesses he does like… yeah… they should open up soon.

(One can only imagine the list of “first to open” businesses had this happened in a Bill Clinton administration if he asserted the same political philosophy of Presidential largess.)

In Texas (Texas?!?) a judge demanded that a woman operating her hair salon bend the knee before him and admit to being “selfish”, apologize for her “counter-revolutionary” behavior, and seek the forgiveness of the petit tyran.   She refused and was promptly jailed.  Fortunately, the Supreme Court of Texas intervened and she was released from custody. 

This elevation of the ruling class to the status of “master” will have massive unintended consequences.  It also uniquely gives states like California, that have long languished under collectivist colonization, an opportunity to finally free itself from serfdom.

This brings us to the Tocqueville Paradox:

(If you have arrived here from our newsletter, continue reading here…)

De Tocqueville noticed something in 1835 when he wrote Democracy in America.  He was trying to understand our national character, and how we became who we are.  To do this he compared our young republic to Ancient Rome and Ancient Greece.  He noticed a paradoxical pattern that began to appear again and again.  While this epiphany was by no means the central core of his writing, his recognition of it has earned him the moniker.  Essentially, the Tocqueville Paradox states that when a dictatorship begins to overextend its power against its own citizens, the State itself becomes threatened.  When a “strongman”  (sorry… ”strong person”) rules in an arbitrary manner at the expense of the body politic, there is only so much annoyance that the people are prepared to endure.  Once a certain point is reached, the ruling class, in an effort to maintain its status, “arranges” for a removal of the “strong-person”.  That person is then replaced with a “reformer”.  This is where the paradox kicks into high gear.  Though the “reformer” begins to ease the restrictions of the predecessor, this newfound freedom creates a cascade event that ultimately and quickly leads to the complete overthrow of the ruling class. 

We saw this in Ancient Greece, we saw this in Ancient Rome, we saw this in Ancient China, we have seen this in Modern Germany, Modern Russia, and now… perhaps… Modern California, Modern New York, and Modern Michigan.

The people are beginning to realize that the Mandarins are incompetent and inept.  They have created a beast we must pay for that sits beside us daily and supplants our decisions with its decisions. 

One of the most interesting things to watch on a large-scale social level was how China switched from its One-Child Policy to its now Two-Child Policy.  For years China promulgated to their citizens that the One-Child Policy would lead to happiness and economic prosperity.  Its local apparatchiks carried out this policy through social pressure, patronage, forced abortions, and imprisonment.  It was cruel and barbarous… but it came to the people from learned “scientists” in the Central Committee. 

Then they changed it. 

It was no longer a good idea.  The Politburo realized that its demographics were on a crash course with economic realties… it needed more “people”.   The propaganda needed to be switched and sterilized immediately!  Now it is a Two-Child Policy that will bring happiness and rainbows!

Yet those who were heavily involved in the One-Child Policy were simply cast aside.  They were no longer “useful”… but they were, and are still, citizens of China.  Suddenly the government telling them what to do… what decisions they must make is laid bare as corrupt, at the worst, inept at the best. 

What will happen here in the States?  Will the “leaders” in our dictatorial States be “removed from power” by the entrenched Mandarins seeking to maintain their control?  Quite possibly… then the “reformer” will emerge.

For what happens after that… we should remember De Tocqueville, and be prepared for a new regime based on limited government, liberty, protection of the minority, and a political philosophy that is fundamentally rooted in the dignity of the individual.  Then, once again, we renew our belief that government is empowered by The People… that The People have instituted government for the singular purpose of securing the rights granted to all by their Creator.

Recent Posts

Saint Alive! Blog - Catacombs

Saints Alive!

The sounds of dripping were muffled by the hiss of the torch.  I could feel the oil-laden rag at the end of the truncheon burning

Read More »
PAGA(Private Attorneys General Act) Blog


One of the most infuriating aspects of Constitutional Law is the need to remain philosophically consistent, even when… especially when… outcomes on specific cases seem

Read More »
Cain Abel & the Vote Blog

Cain, Abel, and the Vote

Why did Cain kill Abel?     Seriously… what was the real motivation?  Jealousy?  That seems like a spectacularly one-dimensional excuse frankly.  I think it

Read More »

Comments (4)

  • Jim L Reply

    Awesome article… the most hope stirring idea gleaned from historical evidence have seen yet. Thank you!

    05/13/2020 at 08:49
  • Ron Winship Reply

    “The greatest Dictators of all time, were also the best at using the rights of the people against themselves. Derogatory Free Speech is really nothing more that yelling “Fire in a packed theater!” when there is no fire. We live in new age of instant communication. No doubt these words will be in a thousand locations by the time we have made the last click on our computer. Our country however is based solely upon not only the “Word of God”, but a great “Social Contract”. It took many years, deaths and enslavement reversed
    to balance “Sheep herders and Cattle Barons”, “Railroad Magnets and Native American Lands”, “The Trail of Tears against the great Western Expansion” and “Manifest Destiny”, the “Alien and Sedition Acts” against a great expanding economy. Alexis Toqueville, took a snapshot of a “New Vision” of what Government might be without the class systems of Europe. When he came to the United States, slavery was flourishing, Native Tribes were being isolated and exterminated by a variety of means, not just militarily. The inequities in our society…..seemed such a conflict… quasi acceptance of a land full of opportunity and not enough people to create business and enterprise. In 1835, the Dutch Traders were still bringing Black Slaves to the Carolinas from Aftica.
    The events of the Corona Virus -19 remind us of what true equality might mean. Regardless of sex, race or national heritage, anyone can be infected, infect friends, neighbors, family and anyone they come in contact with. Social Responsibility means more than just not robbing your local liquor store, or speeding at 100 MPH thusly endangering anyone in your path. The lack of personal responsibility in this country can be seen every night on the nightly news when people engage in needless Car Chases and take away Public Safety Officers from doing their normal duties. We have some Governors, Congress People and Bureaucrats which believe that they are ABOVE the LAW and can do anything. Others think that Public Safety should be the first priority
    of government…….one thing is sure…..we will know the answers in the months to come.

    05/13/2020 at 12:25
  • Bill Farone Reply

    Let us not forget Maximilien Robespierre, an inevitable part of the Paradox. He got exactly what he wanted the French rulers to have as he became the icon of the new rulers. Currently the science being used to undermine the Constitution is what we could define as Political Science across the political spectrum. The rulers pick and choose the science they wish to support the politics. How really bad is COVID-19? Consider that every year 440,000 people die from smoking related disease. Laws passed in 2009 allow the FDA to stop that. They have not. No one has closed the economy to stop that death rate which continues even with fewer people smoking tobacco. No one has held daily conferences and there is no doubt at all about the science.

    05/13/2020 at 14:11
  • Olaf Reply

    Great parody!

    05/17/2020 at 13:01

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *